| Player | Match Date | Age (Days) |
|---|---|---|
| Keith Mercer | 16/02/1973 | 16y 4m 2d (5,969) |
| Gifton Noel-Williams | 24/09/1996 | 16y 8m 3d (6,091) |
| Alex Campana (A) | 23/08/2005 | 16y 10m 12d (6,160) |
| Gilbert Wilkinson | 05/03/1927 | 16y 10m 13d (6,163) |
| Kieron Forbes (A) | 14/08/2007 | 16y 11m 28d (6,206) |
| Arthur Grimsdell | 22/04/1911 | 17y 0m 30d (6,238) |
| Tomiwa Akinyimika (A) | 25/08/2026 | 17y 1m 6d (6,246) |
| Adrian Blake (A) | 23/08/2022 | 17y 1m 8d (6,248) |
| Jordan Parkes (A) | 19/09/2006 | 17y 1m 24d (6,264) |
| Junior Osborne (A) | 08/05/2005 | 17y 2m 26d (6,295) |
| Theo Robinson (A) | 22/04/2006 | 17y 3m 0d (6,299) |
| David Pygall | 28/04/1956 | 17y 3m 5d (6,305) |
| Alhassan Bangura (A) | 30/04/2005 | 17y 3m 6d (6,306) |
| Tommie Hoban (A) | 07/05/2011 | 17y 3m 13d (6,312) |
| Michael Adu-Poku (A) | 07/01/2023 | 17y 3m 16d (6,316) |
| Zavier Massiah-Edwards (A) | 04/05/2024 | 17y 3m 18d (6,318) |
| Wally Eames | 27/04/1901 | 17y 4m 15d (6,345) |
| John Watt | 29/04/1972 | 17y 5m 6d (6,367) |
| Trevor How | 18/01/1975 | 17y 5m 10d (6,372) |
| Dennis Bond | 29/08/1964 | 17y 5m 12d (6,375) |
| Tommy Smith | 18/11/1997 | 17y 5m 27d (6,389) |
| Johnny Williams | 22/09/1964 | 17y 5m 27d (6,390) |
| Rod Thomas | 15/04/1988 | 17y 6m 5d (6,397) |
| Gavin Massey (A) | 02/05/2010 | 17y 6m 18d (6,409) |
| Sean Murray (A) | 30/04/2011 | 17y 6m 19d (6,410) |
| Amin Nabizada (A) | 09/01/2025 | 17y 6m 19d (6,412) |
| Jimmy Gilligan | 22/08/1981 | 17y 6m 29d (6,420) |
| Darren Bazeley | 05/05/1990 | 17y 7m 0d (6,421) |
| Lee Hodson (A) | 03/05/2009 | 17y 7m 1d (6,423) |
| Chris Johnson | 27/08/1996 | 17y 7m 2d (6,424) |