| 01/01/2026 | | Tom Ince (3) | Birmingham City (H) | Win (3-0) | League (Tier 2) |
| 02/11/2024 | | Vakoun Bayo (4) | Sheffield Wednesday (A) | Win (6-2) | League (Tier 2) |
| 13/08/2024 | | Tom Ince (3) | MK Dons (H) | Win (5-0) | Football League Cup |
| 23/10/2021 | | Joshua King (3) | Everton (A) | Win (5-2) | League (Tier 1) |
| 22/02/2019 | | Gerard Deulofeu (3) | Cardiff City (A) | Win (5-1) | League (Tier 1) |
| 24/01/2015 | | Odion Ighalo (4) | Blackpool (H) | Win (7-2) | League (Tier 2) |
| 05/12/2014 | | Troy Deeney (3) | Fulham (A) | Win (5-0) | League (Tier 2) |
| 10/08/2013 | | Troy Deeney (3) | AFC Bournemouth (H) | Win (6-1) | League (Tier 2) |
| 05/04/2003 | | Michael Chopra (4) | Burnley (A) | Win (7-4) | League (Tier 2) |
| 04/11/1997 | | Peter Kennedy (3) | Southend United (A) | Win (3-0) | League (Tier 3) |
| 07/12/1996 | | David Connolly (3) | Ashford Town (H) | Win (5-0) | FA Cup |
| 23/04/1996 | | David Connolly (3) | Grimsby Town (H) | Win (6-3) | League (Tier 2) |
| 23/04/1996 | | Craig Ramage (3) | Grimsby Town (H) | Win (6-3) | League (Tier 2) |
| 13/04/1996 | | David Connolly (3) | Port Vale (H) | Win (5-2) | League (Tier 2) |
| 04/02/1995 | | Darren Bazeley (3) | Southend United (A) | Win (4-0) | League (Tier 2) |
| 15/01/1994 | | Paul Furlong (3) | Birmingham City (H) | Win (5-2) | League (Tier 2) |
| 23/10/1993 | | Gary Porter (3) | Bolton Wanderers (H) | Win (4-3) | League (Tier 2) |
| 13/04/1991 | | Paul Wilkinson (3) | Wolverhampton Wanderers (H) | Win (3-1) | League (Tier 2) |
| 18/10/1986 | | Mark Falco (3) | Aston Villa (H) | Win (4-2) | League (Tier 1) |
| 24/08/1985 | | Colin West (3) | West Bromwich Albion (H) | Win (5-1) | League (Tier 1) |
| 05/01/1985 | | Luther Blissett (4) | Sheffield United (H) | Win (5-0) | FA Cup |
| 25/09/1984 | | John Barnes (3) | Cardiff City (H) | Win (3-1) | Football League Cup |
| 03/12/1983 | | Mo Johnston (3) | Wolverhampton Wanderers (A) | Win (5-0) | League (Tier 1) |
| 12/03/1983 | | Luther Blissett (3) | Notts County (H) | Win (5-3) | League (Tier 1) |
| 25/09/1982 | | Luther Blissett (4) | Sunderland (H) | Win (8-0) | League (Tier 1) |
| 28/10/1980 | | Ross Anthony Jenkins (3) | Nottingham Forest (H) | Win (4-1) | Football League Cup |
| 25/11/1978 | | Ross Anthony Jenkins (3) | Dagenham (H) | Win (3-0) | FA Cup |
| 23/09/1978 | | Ross Anthony Jenkins (4) | Oxford United (H) | Win (4-2) | League (Tier 3) |
| 22/08/1978 | | Ross Anthony Jenkins (3) | Blackpool (H) | Win (5-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 21/01/1978 | | Alan Mayes (3) | York City (A) | Win (4-0) | League (Tier 4) |
| 29/10/1977 | | Keith Mercer (3) | Crewe Alexandra (H) | Win (5-2) | League (Tier 4) |
| 24/08/1976 | | Ross Anthony Jenkins (3) | Hartlepool (H) | Win (4-0) | League (Tier 4) |
| 19/04/1976 | | Keith Mercer (3) | Exeter City (A) | Win (3-1) | League (Tier 4) |
| 02/02/1974 | | Billy Jennings (3) | Tranmere Rovers (H) | Win (4-2) | League (Tier 3) |
| 29/12/1973 | | Pat Morrissey (3) | Oldham Athletic (A) | Win (3-0) | League (Tier 3) |
| 31/08/1973 | | Billy Jennings (3) | Southend United (A) | Win (3-2) | League (Tier 3) |
| 06/01/1971 | | Barry Endean (3) | Reading (H) | Win (5-0) | FA Cup |
| 11/01/1969 | | Barry Endean (3) | Gillingham (A) | Win (5-0) | League (Tier 3) |
| 12/04/1968 | | Barry Dyson (4) | Northampton Town (H) | Win (5-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 02/12/1967 | | Tony Currie (3) | Grimsby Town (H) | Win (7-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 18/11/1967 | | Terry Garbett (3) | Reading (H) | Win (3-0) | League (Tier 3) |
| 26/09/1967 | | Tony Currie (3) | Peterborough United (H) | Win (4-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 16/04/1965 | | Jimmy McAnearney (3) | Scunthorpe United (H) | Win (5-0) | League (Tier 3) |
| 26/12/1964 | | George Harris (3) | Luton Town (A) | Win (4-2) | League (Tier 3) |
| 29/12/1962 | | Dai Ward (3) | Carlisle United (H) | Win (5-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 02/09/1961 | | Tommy Williams (3) | Torquay United (A) | Win (4-3) | League (Tier 3) |
| 30/08/1960 | | Freddie Bunce (3) | Brentford (H) | Win (6-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 30/08/1960 | | Cliff Holton (3) | Brentford (H) | Win (6-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 16/04/1960 | | Cliff Holton (3) | Gateshead (H) | Win (5-0) | League (Tier 4) |
| 15/04/1960 | | Cliff Holton (3) | Chester (H) | Win (4-2) | League (Tier 4) |
| 17/11/1959 | | Dennis Uphill (3) | Cheltenham Town (H) | Win (3-0) | FA Cup |
| 13/10/1959 | | Cliff Holton (3) | Hartlepools United (H) | Win (7-2) | League (Tier 4) |
| 03/10/1959 | | Cliff Holton (3) | Walsall (A) | Win (4-3) | League (Tier 4) |
| 20/09/1958 | | Sammy Chung (3) | Workington (H) | Win (3-0) | League (Tier 4) |
| 07/12/1957 | | Tommy McMillan (3) | Exeter City (H) | Win (5-4) | League (Tier 3) |
| 05/10/1957 | | Tommy McMillan (3) | Millwall (A) | Win (3-2) | League (Tier 3) |
| 19/11/1955 | | Les Graham (3) | Ramsgate Athletic (H) | Win (5-3) | FA Cup |
| 30/03/1955 | | Maurice Cook (4) | Millwall (H) | Win (5-3) | League (Tier 3) |
| 06/11/1954 | | Maurice Cook (3) | Walsall (H) | Win (4-0) | League (Tier 3) |
| 07/09/1954 | | Roy Brown (3) | Crystal Palace (H) | Win (7-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 26/12/1951 | | Cyril Thompson (3) | Northampton Town (A) | Win (4-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 13/10/1951 | | Cyril Thompson (3) | Newport County (A) | Win (5-2) | League (Tier 3) |
| 25/12/1946 | | Ralph Evans (3) | Southend United (H) | Win (4-0) | League (Tier 3) |
| 11/03/1939 | | Len Dunderdale (3) | Exeter City (A) | Win (3-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 13/09/1937 | | Bill Black (4) | Notts County (H) | Win (8-3) | Division 3 [South] Cup |
| 06/03/1937 | | Len Fletcher (3) | Crystal Palace (H) | Win (3-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 05/09/1936 | | Taffy Davies (4) | Gillingham (H) | Win (6-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 18/04/1936 | | Tom Walters (3) | Southend United (H) | Win (5-0) | League (Tier 3) |
| 04/04/1936 | | Tom Walters (3) | Cardiff City (H) | Win (4-0) | League (Tier 3) |
| 08/02/1936 | | Bill Devan (3) | Coventry City (H) | Win (5-0) | League (Tier 3) |
| 01/02/1936 | | Len Fletcher (3) | Swindon Town (A) | Win (6-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 25/01/1936 | | Frank McPherson (3) | Leicester City (A) | Loss (3-6) | FA Cup |
| 11/01/1936 | | Tommy Barnett (3) | Southall (A) | Win (4-1) | FA Cup |
| 15/12/1934 | | Billy Lane (3) | Swindon Town (H) | Win (7-4) | League (Tier 3) |
| 24/10/1934 | | Billy Lane (3) | Bristol City (H) | Win (4-1) | Division 3 [South] Cup |
| 20/12/1933 | | Billy Lane (3) | Clapton Orient (H) | Win (6-0) | League (Tier 3) |
| 25/02/1933 | | Billy Lane (3) | Gillingham (A) | Draw (3-3) | League (Tier 3) |
| 26/09/1931 | | Tommy Barnett (3) | Bournemouth & Boscombe Athletic (H) | Win (4-2) | League (Tier 3) |
| 12/09/1931 | | George James (3) | Bristol Rovers (H) | Win (5-2) | League (Tier 3) |
| 05/09/1931 | | George James (3) | Torquay United (A) | Win (6-3) | League (Tier 3) |
| 29/11/1930 | | George James (3) | Walthamstow Avenue (A) | Win (5-1) | FA Cup |
| 22/11/1930 | | Tommy Barnett (4) | Torquay United (H) | Win (6-0) | League (Tier 3) |
| 25/10/1930 | | Bob White (3) | Newport County (H) | Win (6-2) | League (Tier 3) |
| 18/10/1930 | | George James (3) | Bristol Rovers (A) | Win (5-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 11/09/1930 | | George James (3) | Queens Park Rangers (A) | Win (3-2) | League (Tier 3) |
| 26/04/1930 | | George James (3) | Southend United (A) | Win (3-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 21/04/1930 | | Tommy Barnett (3) | Swindon Town (H) | Win (4-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 05/04/1930 | | George James (3) | Gillingham (H) | Win (4-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 30/11/1929 | | Frank McPherson (3) | Ilford (A) | Win (3-0) | FA Cup |
| 29/03/1929 | | Frank McPherson (3) | Walsall (H) | Win (4-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 09/02/1929 | | Frank McPherson (3) | Fulham (A) | Win (3-2) | League (Tier 3) |
| 02/02/1929 | | Tommy Barnett (3) | Plymouth Argyle (H) | Win (6-3) | League (Tier 3) |
| 17/11/1928 | | Frank McPherson (3) | Southend United (H) | Win (4-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 27/12/1927 | | Bill Sheppard (3) | Gillingham (A) | Win (3-0) | League (Tier 3) |
| 27/11/1926 | | Jack Swan (3) | Lowestoft Town (H) | Win (10-1) | FA Cup |
| 27/11/1926 | | Jack Warner (3) | Lowestoft Town (H) | Win (10-1) | FA Cup |
| 09/10/1926 | | Eddie Edmonds (3) | Gillingham (H) | Win (4-0) | League (Tier 3) |
| 13/03/1926 | | Fred Pagnam (3) | Merthyr Town (H) | Win (6-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 07/11/1925 | | Jack Swan (3) | Newport County (H) | Win (5-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 18/04/1925 | | Fred Pagnam (3) | Brentford (H) | Win (3-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 01/03/1924 | | Fred Pagnam (3) | Exeter City (H) | Win (4-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 05/01/1924 | | Eddie Mummery (5) | Newport County (H) | Win (8-2) | League (Tier 3) |
| 10/03/1923 | | Fred Pagnam (3) | Aberdare Athletic (H) | Win (6-0) | League (Tier 3) |
| 28/10/1922 | | Fred Pagnam (3) | Gillingham (H) | Win (5-2) | League (Tier 3) |
| 21/10/1922 | | Fred Pagnam (3) | Gillingham (A) | Win (4-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 30/09/1922 | | Fred Pagnam (3) | Exeter City (H) | Win (4-0) | League (Tier 3) |
| 26/04/1922 | | Frank Smith (3) | Southend United (A) | Win (4-1) | League (Tier 3) |
| 13/03/1920 | | Eddie Edmonds (5) | Merthyr Town (A) | Win (6-3) | Southern League |
| 15/11/1919 | | Peter Ronald (3) | Plymouth Argyle (H) | Win (3-0) | Southern League |
| 01/11/1919 | | Charlie White (3) | Merthyr Town (H) | Win (5-0) | Southern League |
| 06/09/1919 | | Eddie Edmonds (3) | Crystal Palace (H) | Win (4-1) | Southern League |
| 03/10/1914 | | Tommy Waterall (3) | Millwall (A) | Win (3-0) | Southern League |
| 01/04/1914 | | Thomas Ashbridge (4) | West Ham United (H) | Win (6-0) | Southern League |
| 29/11/1913 | | Thomas Ashbridge (5) | Bournemouth (H) | Win (10-0) | FA Cup |
| 29/11/1913 | | Val Gregory (3) | Bournemouth (H) | Win (10-0) | FA Cup |
| 24/09/1913 | | Eddie Edmonds (4) | Coventry City (H) | Win (7-0) | Southern League |
| 04/12/1912 | | Arthur Squires (3) | Brentford (H) | Win (5-1) | FA Cup |
| 20/11/1909 | | Jimmy Maclaine (3) | Bromley (H) | Win (8-1) | FA Cup |
| 25/04/1908 | | Harry Smith (3) | Crystal Palace (H) | Win (4-1) | Southern League |
| 19/10/1907 | | Jack Foster (3) | Reading (H) | Win (4-0) | Southern League |
| 19/01/1907 | | Tommy Niblo (3) | Leyton (H) | Win (6-2) | Southern League |
| 28/02/1906 | | Jack Foster (4) | Grays United (H) | Win (10-1) | United League |
| 24/02/1906 | | Fred Spiksley (3) | Northampton Town (H) | Win (5-3) | Southern League |
| 15/03/1905 | | Johnny Goodall (3) | Southern United (H) | Win (7-0) | South Eastern League |
| 25/01/1905 | | Harry Barton (3) | Eastbourne Old Town (H) | Win (10-0) | South Eastern League |
| 14/01/1905 | | Peter Turner (3) | St Leonards United (H) | Win (6-0) | South Eastern League |
| 29/10/1904 | | Wally Eames (3) | Biggleswade (H) | Win (7-1) | FA Cup |
| 09/04/1904 | | Harry Barton (3) | War Office (H) | Win (8-1) | South Eastern League |
| 05/03/1904 | | Bertie Banks (3) | Wycombe Wanderers (A) | Win (5-0) | Southern League |
| 09/01/1904 | | Wally Eames (4) | Chesham Generals (H) | Win (6-0) | South Eastern League |
| 02/01/1904 | | Bertie Banks (3) | Southall (H) | Win (10-0) | Southern League |
| 02/01/1904 | | Harry Barton (3) | Southall (H) | Win (10-0) | Southern League |
| 19/12/1903 | | Bertie Banks (3) | Grays United (H) | Win (8-0) | South Eastern League |
| 12/12/1903 | | Harry Barton (3) | Fulham Reserves (A) | Draw (3-3) | Southern League |
| 05/12/1903 | | Bertie Banks (3) | Swindon Town Reserves (H) | Win (6-1) | Southern League |
| 24/10/1903 | | Bertie Banks (3) | Hitchin Town (H) | Win (9-0) | South Eastern League |
| 24/10/1903 | | Johnny Goodall (3) | Hitchin Town (H) | Win (9-0) | South Eastern League |
| 26/09/1903 | | Harry Barton (6) | Wycombe Wanderers (H) | Win (9-0) | Southern League |
| 12/09/1903 | | Bertie Banks (3) | Portsmouth Reserves (H) | Win (6-1) | Southern League |
| 05/09/1903 | | Harry Barton (3) | Grays United (A) | Win (3-1) | Southern League |
| 08/11/1902 | | Taffy Morgan (3) | Swindon Town (H) | Win (5-3) | Southern League |
| 03/11/1900 | | Charlie Hare (3) | Leighton Cee Springs (H) | Win (10-0) | FA Cup |
| 14/04/1900 | | Charlie Hare (3) | Wandsworth (H) | Win (6-0) | Bucks & Contiguous Counties League |
| 15/03/1900 | | Charlie Hare (3) | Aylesbury United (A) | Win (8-3) | Bucks & Contiguous Counties League |
| 24/02/1900 | | Jack McNee (4) | Maidenhead (H) | Win (11-0) | Southern League |
| 25/12/1899 | | Bobbie Slaughter (3) | Southall (H) | Win (6-1) | Southern League |
| 30/09/1899 | | Charlie Hare (3) | Hitchin Town (H) | Win (7-1) | FA Cup |
| 30/09/1899 | | Bobbie Slaughter (4) | Hitchin Town (H) | Win (7-1) | FA Cup |
| 27/09/1899 | | Charlie Hare (4) | Aylesbury United (H) | Win (10-0) | Bucks & Contiguous Counties League |
| 27/04/1899 | | Jack McNee (4) | Aylesbury United (A) | Win (7-1) | Bucks & Contiguous Counties League |
| 28/01/1899 | | Johnny Hill (3) | Fulham (H) | Win (6-3) | Southern League |
| 14/01/1899 | | Bobbie Slaughter (3) | Uxbridge (A) | Win (4-1) | Southern League |
| 22/10/1898 | | Charlie Hare (3) | Shepherds Bush (H) | Win (7-0) | Southern League |
| 14/09/1898 | | Tuggy Beach (3) | Wycombe Wanderers (H) | Win (15-0) | Bucks & Contiguous Counties League |
| 14/09/1898 | | Charlie Hare (4) | Wycombe Wanderers (H) | Win (15-0) | Bucks & Contiguous Counties League |
| 14/09/1898 | | Johnny Hill (4) | Wycombe Wanderers (H) | Win (15-0) | Bucks & Contiguous Counties League |