| Alessio Dionisi (1) | 1 | Kwadwo Baah, Marc Bola, Edoardo Bove, Iker Bravo, Mamadou Doumbia, Edo Kayembe, Kévin Keben, Luca Kjerrumgaard, Hector Kyprianou, Othmane Maamma, Amin Nabizada, Martín Payero, Mattie Pollock, Federico Ravaglia, Omar Traoré, Rocco Vata |
| Ed Still (15) | 15 | Imrân Louza, Nampalys Mendy, Egil Selvik |
| Paulo Pezzolano (10) | 10 | Kwadwo Baah, Nestory Irankunda |
| Tom Cleverley (59) | 55 | Edo Kayembe |
| Valérien Ismaël (41) | 41 | Wesley Hoedt |
| Chris Wilder (11) | 11 | Imrân Louza, Ryan Porteous, Ken Sema |
| Slaven Bilić (26) | 25 | Daniel Bachmann |
| Rob Edwards (11) | 11 | Edo Kayembe, Ken Sema |
| Roy Hodgson (18) | 18 | Moussa Sissoko |
| Claudio Ranieri (14) | 14 | João Pedro, Moussa Sissoko |
| Xisco Muñoz (36) | 32 | Ken Sema |
| Vladimir Ivić (22) | 20 | Ben Foster |
| Nigel Pearson (22) | 20 | Troy Deeney, Ben Foster |
| Javi Gracia (87) | 59 | Abdoulaye Doucouré |
| Marco Silva (26) | 26 | Richarlison |
| Walter Mazzarri (41) | 40 | Troy Deeney |
| Quique Flores (56) | 49 | Craig Cathcart |
| Slaviša Jokanović (36) | 36 | Troy Deeney |
| Billy McKinlay (2) | 2 | Almen Abdi, Ikechi Anya, Lloyd Dyer, Joel Ekstrand, Heurelho Gomes, Tommie Hoban, Gianni Munari, Juan Carlos Paredes, Dániel Tozsér, Matej Vydra |
| Òscar García (4) | 4 | Ikechi Anya, Lloyd Dyer, Joel Ekstrand, Heurelho Gomes, Juan Carlos Paredes, Daniel Pudil, Dániel Tozsér, Matej Vydra |
| Beppe Sannino (36) | 34 | Troy Deeney |
| Gianfranco Zola (75) | 62 | Troy Deeney |
| Sean Dyche (49) | 46 | Troy Deeney |
| Malky Mackay (99) | 98 | Danny Graham, Adrian Mariappa |
| Brendan Rodgers (31) | 31 | Scott Loach, Adrian Mariappa |
| Adrian Boothroyd (176) | 132 | Jay DeMerit, Lloyd Doyley |
| Ray Lewington (150) | 128 | Neal Ardley |
| Gianluca Vialli (52) | 45 | Neil Cox, Tommy Smith |
| Kenny Jackett (57) | 56 | Nigel Gibbs |
| Glenn Roeder (141) | 115 | Gary Porter |
| Steve Perryman (135) | 133 | Keith Dublin |
| Colin Lee (31) | 31 | Paul Wilkinson |
| Steve Harrison (124) | 123 | Tony Coton |
| Dave Bassett (29) | 29 | John McClelland, Mark Morris, Gary Porter |
| Graham Taylor (756) | 410 | Luther Blissett |
| Mike Keen (196) | 185 | Andy Rankin |
| George Kirby (97) | 94 | Colin Franks |
| Ken Furphy (331) | 322 | Duncan Welbourne |
| Bill McGarry (62) | 62 | George Harris |
| Ron Burgess (228) | 195 | Vince McNeice |
| Johnny Paton (18) | 18 | Maurice Cook |
| Len Goulden (160) | 134 | Frank Mitchell |
| Haydn Green (56) | 52 | Tony Collins |
| Ron Gray (57) | 54 | Tommy Eggleston |
| Eddie Hapgood (94) | 90 | Dave Thomas |
| Jackie Bray (37) | 36 | Taffy Davies |
| Bill Findlay (142) | 104 | Vic O'Brien |
| Neil McBain (513) | 327 | Arthur Woodward |
| Fred Pagnam (133) | 120 | George Prior |
| Harry Kent (523) | 360 | Charlie White |
| John Goodall (333) | 283 | Billy Biggar |