| Alessio Dionisi (6) | 6 | Edoardo Bove, Mamadou Doumbia, Edo Kayembe, Kévin Keben, Hector Kyprianou, Othmane Maamma, Amin Nabizada, Rocco Vata |
| Ed Still (15) | 15 | Imrân Louza, Nampalys Mendy, Egil Selvik |
| Paulo Pezzolano (10) | 10 | Kwadwo Baah, Nestory Irankunda |
| Tom Cleverley (59) | 55 | Edo Kayembe |
| Valérien Ismaël (41) | 41 | Wesley Hoedt |
| Chris Wilder (11) | 11 | Imrân Louza, Ryan Porteous, Ken Sema |
| Slaven Bilić (26) | 25 | Daniel Bachmann |
| Rob Edwards (11) | 11 | Edo Kayembe, Ken Sema |
| Roy Hodgson (18) | 18 | Moussa Sissoko |
| Claudio Ranieri (14) | 14 | João Pedro, Moussa Sissoko |
| Xisco Muñoz (36) | 32 | Ken Sema |
| Vladimir Ivić (22) | 20 | Ben Foster |
| Nigel Pearson (22) | 20 | Troy Deeney, Ben Foster |
| Javi Gracia (87) | 59 | Abdoulaye Doucouré |
| Marco Silva (26) | 26 | Richarlison |
| Walter Mazzarri (41) | 40 | Troy Deeney |
| Quique Flores (56) | 49 | Craig Cathcart |
| Slaviša Jokanović (36) | 36 | Troy Deeney |
| Billy McKinlay (2) | 2 | Almen Abdi, Ikechi Anya, Lloyd Dyer, Joel Ekstrand, Heurelho Gomes, Tommie Hoban, Gianni Munari, Juan Carlos Paredes, Dániel Tozsér, Matej Vydra |
| Òscar García (4) | 4 | Ikechi Anya, Lloyd Dyer, Joel Ekstrand, Heurelho Gomes, Juan Carlos Paredes, Daniel Pudil, Dániel Tozsér, Matej Vydra |
| Beppe Sannino (36) | 34 | Troy Deeney |
| Gianfranco Zola (75) | 62 | Troy Deeney |
| Sean Dyche (49) | 46 | Troy Deeney |
| Malky Mackay (99) | 98 | Danny Graham, Adrian Mariappa |
| Brendan Rodgers (31) | 31 | Scott Loach, Adrian Mariappa |
| Adrian Boothroyd (176) | 132 | Jay DeMerit, Lloyd Doyley |
| Ray Lewington (150) | 128 | Neal Ardley |
| Gianluca Vialli (52) | 45 | Neil Cox, Tommy Smith |
| Kenny Jackett (57) | 56 | Nigel Gibbs |
| Glenn Roeder (141) | 115 | Gary Porter |
| Steve Perryman (135) | 133 | Keith Dublin |
| Colin Lee (31) | 31 | Paul Wilkinson |
| Steve Harrison (124) | 123 | Tony Coton |
| Dave Bassett (29) | 29 | John McClelland, Mark Morris, Gary Porter |
| Graham Taylor (756) | 410 | Luther Blissett |
| Mike Keen (196) | 185 | Andy Rankin |
| George Kirby (97) | 94 | Colin Franks |
| Ken Furphy (331) | 322 | Duncan Welbourne |
| Bill McGarry (62) | 62 | George Harris |
| Ron Burgess (228) | 195 | Vince McNeice |
| Johnny Paton (18) | 18 | Maurice Cook |
| Len Goulden (160) | 134 | Frank Mitchell |
| Haydn Green (56) | 52 | Tony Collins |
| Ron Gray (57) | 54 | Tommy Eggleston |
| Eddie Hapgood (94) | 90 | Dave Thomas |
| Jackie Bray (37) | 36 | Taffy Davies |
| Bill Findlay (142) | 104 | Vic O'Brien |
| Neil McBain (513) | 327 | Arthur Woodward |
| Fred Pagnam (133) | 120 | George Prior |
| Harry Kent (523) | 360 | Charlie White |
| John Goodall (333) | 283 | Billy Biggar |