| Date | Opposition | Score | Goalkeeper 1 | Goalkeeper 2 | Goalkeeper 3 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 22/09/2025 | Millwall (A) | 0-1 | Egil Selvik (1) | Nathan Baxter (0) | |
| 21/09/2024 | Norwich City (A) | 1-4 | Daniel Bachmann (1) | Jonathan Bond (3) | |
| 06/02/2024 | Southampton (A) | 0-3 | Daniel Bachmann (2) | Ben Hamer (1) | |
| 25/11/2023 | Leicester City (A) | 0-2 | Daniel Bachmann (1) | Ryan Porteous (1) | |
| 05/11/2017 | Everton (A) | 2-3 | Heurelho Gomes (0) | Orestis Karnezis (3) | |
| 29/01/2017 | Millwall (A) | 0-1 | Costel Pantilimon (0) | Heurelho Gomes (1) | |
| 06/11/2016 | Liverpool (A) | 1-6 | Heurelho Gomes (2) | Costel Pantilimon (4) | |
| 28/11/2015 | Aston Villa (A) | 3-2 | Heurelho Gomes (1) | Giedrius Arlauskis (1) | |
| 10/01/2015 | Huddersfield Town (A) | 1-3 | Heurelho Gomes (1) | Jonathan Bond (2) | |
| 04/05/2013 | Leeds United (H) | 1-2 | Jonathan Bond (0) | Jack Bonham (2) | |
| 23/02/2013 | Derby County (H) | 2-1 | Manuel Almunia (1) | Jonathan Bond (1) | |
| 02/01/2012 | Portsmouth (A) | 0-2 | Scott Loach (1) | Jonathan Bond (1) | |
| 27/09/2008 | Sheffield United (A) | 1-2 | Scott Loach (1) | Richard Lee (1) | |
| 20/09/2008 | Reading (H) | 2-2 | Mart Poom (0) | Scott Loach (2) | |
| 18/11/2006 | Portsmouth (A) | 1-2 | Ben Foster (1) | Richard Lee (1) | |
| 14/02/2006 | Leeds United (A) | 1-2 | Ben Foster (0) | Alec Chamberlain (2) | |
| 18/12/2004 | Coventry City (A) | 0-1 | Richard Lee (0) | Alec Chamberlain (1) | |
| 13/12/2003 | Sheffield United (A) | 2-2 | Lenny Pidgeley (1) | Alec Chamberlain (1) | |
| 14/04/2001 | Grimsby Town (A) | 1-2 | Espen Baardsen (0) | Alec Chamberlain (2) | |
| 28/04/1998 | AFC Bournemouth (H) | 2-1 | Stephen Palmer (0) | Alec Chamberlain (1) | |
| 03/09/1994 | Middlesbrough (H) | 1-1 | Kevin Miller (0) | Perry Digweed (1) | |
| 11/10/1986 | Arsenal (A) | 1-3 | Tony Coton (1) | Nigel Callaghan (2) | |
| 25/02/1967 | Middlesbrough (A) | 0-3 | Bert Slater (1) | Keith Eddy (2) | |
| 03/10/1960 | Southend United (A) | 1-6 | Dave Underwood (1) | Cliff Holton (5) | |
| 14/09/1955 | Reading (A) | 1-6 | Ted Bennett (2) | Maurice Cook (1) | Ernie Bateman (3) |
| 04/09/1948 | Crystal Palace (A) | 1-3 | Tommy Rigg (1) | Tommy Harris (2) | |
| 07/12/1946 | Bournemouth & Boscombe Athletic (H) | 0-2 | Tommy Rigg (0) | Ron Gray (2) | |
| 14/10/1933 | Reading (A) | 1-6 | Arthur Slater (2) | Arthur Woodward (4) | |
| 07/10/1933 | Coventry City (H) | 3-3 | Arthur Slater (2) | Arthur Woodward (1) | |
| 18/04/1931 | Crystal Palace (H) | 0-2 | Tom Holland (1) | Joe Davison (1) | |
| 15/03/1924 | Portsmouth (A) | 0-4 | Skilly Williams (2) | George Toone (2) | |
| 01/01/1915 | Cardiff City (A) | 3-2 | Skilly Williams (0) | Tommy Waterall (2) | |
| 26/12/1913 | Gillingham (A) | 0-3 | Joe Webster (2) | Harold Pantling (1) | |
| 27/01/1912 | Millwall (H) | 1-1 | Joe Webster (0) | Chris Bulling (1) | |
| 01/09/1909 | Queens Park Rangers (A) | 3-4 | Billy Biggar (2) | Fred Cleaver (2) | |
| 15/03/1900 | Aylesbury United (A) | 8-3 | Albie Sharp (1) | Jack Cother (2) |